The Human in the Loop

No items found.

AI image generation couldn't do what I needed, so I built a production process around its limitations.

The Problem with Prompting

Early AI image generation tools had a well-documented limitation: they responded to words, not intent. Short phrases. Noun stacks. Anything requiring two subjects in a coherent spatial relationship usually collapsed into something that was neither — ask for a man and a bear and you'd get a chimera. The models weren't broken. They just didn't have art direction.

Most people treated the limitation as a prompting problem — write more, describe more, be more precise. I treated it as a workflow problem.

An AI image model is a generative engine — it produces; it doesn't direct. What it needed was an art director. That's a division of labor that looks new but isn't: new technology often works this way, shifting the lower-order work to the tool and moving the person up the chain. The model generates. The creative director directs.

The T-Hero Campaign

The brief was Meta ads for Essential Elements' T-Hero testosterone line — a supplement brand that needed to stop a scroll, not blend into a feed. An early rough composite, built around the headline "Put the T back in Tough," set the campaign's direction: a man screaming in a gym next to a T-Rex, raw and unresolved. The copywriter pulled it immediately. The campaign would be built around that energy.

The rough that set the direction. The prompt, the raw output, and a two-minute mockup — enough to sell the campaign concept.

That meant producing a series of ads, each pairing a man and a wild animal in a single dramatic scene. Wolf. Elephant. Bear. Dragon. Cinematic. Coherent. Brand-quality.

Early Midjourney couldn't do that in one shot.

The Process

Instead of asking the AI to generate a finished scene, I started treating Midjourney as one part of a larger production workflow, not the whole thing.

Generate each subject separately: the animal in its environment, the human figure independently. Neither output would be final. Composite them in Photoshop to establish spatial relationship, scale, and tension between figures. Then use that composite as a visual reference — feeding it back into Midjourney as an image input, not a text prompt — to push the next generation closer to the intended result. The red shapes marked areas for Adobe Firefly's generative fill to patch in detail before the result went back into the Midjourney loop. Evaluate. Repeat.

Separately generated elements composited in Photoshop. The red masked areas were processed through Adobe Firefly's generative fill before the composite re-entered the Midjourney generation loop.

It was art direction. Aimed at a machine instead of a photographer.

Two different Midjourney-generated bears — same prompt direction, different outputs. Knowing which one to keep required visual judgment the tool doesn't have.

The process was slower than a prompt. It required real Photoshop skill and genuine art direction instincts at every stage. The results couldn't have come from a prompt alone.

The Campaign

This became the production method for everything we built on the T-Hero brand.

Early in the engagement, we developed a wide range of creative directions in parallel — emotional, absurdist, cinematic action. Each required its own generation strategy: different prompt structures, different compositing approaches, different ways of guiding the model toward a specific visual intent.

Three different creative directions explored in parallel — each required a different approach to get the AI to produce something usable.

The man-and-animal concept went to market: four ads running on Meta, each pairing a different man with a different animal in a different environment.

Beast Mode is Calling — T-Hero Platinum ad
Dominate with T-Hero Platinum ad
Crush the Competition — T-Hero Platinum ad
Be Legendary — T-Hero Platinum ad

Results

The campaign ran on Facebook and Instagram. Performance data wasn't shared with the creative team, but competitor ads using the man-animal pairing format started appearing in feeds within months of launch. The format didn't exist in the supplement category before this campaign.

Imitation.

On AI and Art Direction

The specific workarounds here were responses to early Midjourney's limitations. Those particular limitations have largely been solved.

What hasn't changed: knowing what a tool can't do, and building a process that gets there anyway.

Back to Top

Let’s Explore Together

I’m drawn to strange questions, bold ideas, and the edges of what’s possible. If you’re here to make meaning—or make something beautiful—drop me a line. Don’t be shy. Let’s make something weird and wonderful.

Thank you! Your transmission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.